Unclaimed

Unclaimed #11: Your Google Business Profile Is Out There. You Don't Control It. Here's How to Take It Back.

5 of the 11 accounting firms I audited in one market town had unclaimed Google Business Profiles.

Not because they didn't care. Not because they had anything to hide. Because at some point in the last decade, someone tried to claim the profile, hit a verification gate they didn't understand, and never came back.

One of those firms had 22 five-star reviews spanning 7 years. Clients naming the partner. "Worth their weight in gold." The profile was unclaimed. They couldn't say thank you even if they wanted to.

Your profile is probably out there right now. You might control it. You might not. Most accounting firm owners don't know which camp they're in until they try to make a change and Google blocks them.

This is the guide I wish existed when I started auditing firms. Everything I've learned from 300+ audits about claiming, verifying, and taking back control of a Google Business Profile — written for accountants who don't have an afternoon to spend on Google's help pages.

The market town audit taught me something I should have seen coming.

I'd spent hours researching 11 firms. ACCA registration. Audit credentials. Partners with decades of experience. I expected to find neglected profiles — missing descriptions, unanswered reviews, invisible services. I found all of that.

What I didn't expect: nearly half the firms couldn't fix any of it even if they wanted to. Their profiles were unclaimed. "Claim this business" sat there like an unopened letter. They had no access. No control. No ability to respond to the reviews their clients had left them.

One firm had a 1-star rating from a single negative review. Two years old. Unanswered. Both of their office profiles were unclaimed. They couldn't respond to the review. Couldn't add their ACCA credentials. Couldn't post an update. Couldn't do anything except watch that 1-star sit there, visible to every prospect searching "accountant" in their town.

Another firm had seven five-star reviews. Glowing. Detailed. "In a league of its own." The website promised fast response times. The profile showed zero replies. Not because they didn't want to respond. Because nobody at the firm had access to the account that claimed the profile three years ago.

This is not rare. This is normal. And it's the first thing you have to fix before anything else in this Masterclass matters.

The moment most accounting firms give up

Here's how it usually happens.

A partner decides to "sort out the Google thing." They search for the firm on Google Maps. The profile is there. Good. They click "Own this business?" or "Claim this business." Google asks them to verify. They see the options — video recording, postcard, phone call. They weren't prepared for any of this. They close the tab and decide to do it next week.

Next week becomes next month. Next month becomes next year. Three years later, the profile still says "Claim this business." Or worse — it was claimed by someone who left the firm in 2019 and nobody knows the password to their old Gmail account.

I've seen this exact scenario play out at firms of every size. Solo bookkeepers. 10-office practices. Top 100 firms with dedicated marketing teams. Verification friction doesn't discriminate.

The good news: the process is not complicated once you understand it. It's just poorly explained by Google and rarely written about for accounting firms specifically.

First, figure out which situation you're in

Before you do anything else, open an incognito window. Search for your firm name and city on Google. Look at the knowledge panel on the right side of the results. What do you see?

Situation A: "Own this business?" or "Claim this business" Your profile exists but nobody controls it. It was likely auto-generated by Google from directory listings. Anyone could claim it — including you, right now. This is the most common situation I find. You need to claim and verify.

Situation B: The profile looks managed, but you don't know who manages it Someone claimed it. A former partner. An ex-employee. A marketing agency you stopped working with years ago. The profile might look fine — reviews, photos, posts — but you can't access it. This is the most dangerous situation. You need to reclaim ownership.

Situation C: You have access and can make changes You're logged into the right Google account. You can edit the profile. You can respond to reviews. You can post. Skip to the post-verification checklist at the end of this guide and make sure your profile is properly secured.

Situation D: Your firm doesn't appear on Google Maps at all No knowledge panel. No listing. Nothing. You need to create a profile from scratch. Go to Google Business Profile Manager and follow the prompts. Then come back to this guide for the verification section.

The 5 verification methods — what they are, what they test, and why they fail

Google no longer lets you pick your preferred verification method. The system scans your business category, physical address, and web presence, then assigns one or more options automatically.

I've seen firms get every single one of these. Here's what each method actually tests, how long it takes, and the specific failure patterns I've documented across accounting firms.

Method 1: Instant Verification

What it is: Google checks whether your account already has verified ownership of your website domain in Google Search Console. If yes, verification is bypassed completely. No code. No video. No postcard. It just works.

Timeline: Immediate.

Who gets it: Firms that have already verified their website domain in Search Console using the same Google account they're using for GBP. This is most common with firms that have an in-house marketing person or a technically competent web developer who set up Search Console at some point.

Why it fails for accounting firms: The partner trying to claim the profile uses their personal @gmail.com address. The website domain was verified in Search Console by the web developer using their agency account three years ago. Google sees two different accounts and blocks instant verification. The partner doesn't understand why and gives up.

The fix: Before you do anything else, go to Google Search Console and check if your website domain is verified. If it is, use the same Google account for GBP. If it isn't, verify it now. This takes 5 minutes and can save you weeks.

Method 2: Phone or SMS Verification

What it is: Google sends an automated 6-digit code via voice call or text message to the phone number listed on the profile. You enter the code. Done.

Timeline: Within 2 minutes.

Who gets it: Firms with a simple, direct phone number — typically a mobile or a direct landline that rings to a person, not a switchboard.

Why it fails for accounting firms: The firm's main number goes through an automated receptionist ("Press 1 for accounts, press 2 for tax..."). Google's automated system can't navigate the menu. The call fails. Or the phone number on the profile is an old one that hasn't been updated in years. The code goes to a disconnected line or a former employee's mobile.

The fix: Check the phone number on your profile before starting verification. If it's wrong, you may need to use a different verification method first, then update the number after you have access. For firms with IVR systems, ask Google for an alternative method — usually email or postcard.

Method 3: Email Verification

What it is: A 6-digit code is sent to a domain-specific email address associated with the profile.

Timeline: Usually within minutes, can take up to 30 minutes.

Who gets it: Firms with a clear, professional email domain that matches their website.

Why it fails for accounting firms: The firm uses a corporate spam filter — Mimecast, Microsoft Defender, or a strict Outlook policy. Google's automated verification email gets caught in quarantine. Nobody checks the quarantine folder. The code expires. Also fails when the email on file is a former employee's address that no longer exists.

The fix: Whitelist @google.com in your email security settings before starting. Check spam and quarantine folders. If the email on file is wrong, you'll need to use the ownership reclamation process described later in this guide.

Method 4: Video Verification

What it is: You film a continuous, unedited video on your mobile phone proving that you operate at the business address. Google's automated system reviews the footage. This is now the default method for most new verifications and address changes.

Timeline: 3 to 5 working days.

Who gets it: Most firms creating a new profile, changing their address, or verifying after a failed attempt with other methods.

Why it fails for accounting firms: I've documented three specific failure patterns:

  1. No access proof. The firm films their office interior — desks, computers, signage — but never shows them unlocking the door or entering a security code. Google can't verify they control the space, only that they visited it.

  2. Edited footage. The partner trims a few seconds off the beginning or end. Google's automated review detects the edit and rejects the entire submission.

  3. Location mismatch. The firm's registered address is a serviced office or Regus space. The video shows a desk but no permanent branding. Google can't confirm the firm actually operates there versus just renting a mailbox.

The fix: I'll walk through the exact video verification process in detail below. It's the method most firms fail — and the one where preparation makes the difference between approval and rejection.

Method 5: Postcard by Mail

What it is: Google sends a physical postcard to your registered business address. The postcard contains a unique 5-digit verification code. You enter the code online.

Timeline: Up to 14 business days. Sometimes longer.

Who gets it: Firms where other methods have failed, or where Google's system determines physical address verification is necessary. Also common for service-area businesses without a public storefront.

Why it fails for accounting firms: The firm edits their profile while waiting for the postcard. They update their phone number. Change their hours. Modify their address. Any edit during the waiting period instantly invalidates the code before the postcard even arrives. The postcard lands. The code doesn't work. They have to start over.

The fix: Once you request postcard verification, touch nothing. Don't edit your profile. Don't update your phone number. Don't change your hours. Wait the full period. The postcard will arrive. The code will work. Verify first. Edit second.

How to pass video verification — the exact process

Video verification rejects more accounting firms than any other method. It's also the one you're most likely to face. Here is exactly how to pass it on your first attempt.

Before you record

  1. Use a mobile phone, not a desktop webcam. You need to walk through your space.
  2. Enable location services on your phone. Go to Settings → Privacy → Location Services → On.
  3. Give your browser or Google Maps app permission to access your location.
  4. Plan your route: outside → inside → workspace → proof of access. You'll film it in one continuous shot.
  5. Have your keys ready. You need to show yourself unlocking the door.
  6. Clear client names and faces from view. Cover any confidential documents.
  7. Keep the entire recording under 2 minutes. Google's upload gateway enforces a file size limit. Longer recordings may fail to upload or be truncated.

What to film, in order

0:00-0:30 — The exterior. Start on the street. Show the street sign. Show your building number. Show the building entrance. If your firm name appears on a directory board, a brass plaque, or a window sign, film it clearly. For serviced offices: film the building, the directory listing, and your dedicated desk or office number.

0:30-1:00 — The interior. Walk inside. Show your workstations. Film a computer screen displaying accounting software — Sage, Xero, QuickBooks. Show business cards or letterhead with your firm name. For home offices: film the exterior house number, walk inside to your dedicated workspace, and show your HMRC registration or professional body certificate.

1:00-1:30 — The access proof. This is what most firms miss. Film yourself unlocking the office door with a physical key. Or entering a code into a security keypad. Or using an access card on a reader. Google needs to see that you control access to the space, not just that you're standing in it.

What not to do

After submission

Google reviews the footage using automated systems. You'll receive an email with the result within 3-5 working days. If rejected, you'll be told why — usually one of the three failure patterns I described above. Fix the issue and resubmit. You get multiple attempts.

How to reclaim a profile someone else controls

This is the scenario that causes the most anxiety. You find your profile. It's claimed. You don't know who owns it.

I've seen this play out in several ways across my audits:

Here is the exact sequence to take back control.

Step 1: Find out who owns it — if you can

Go to Google Business Profile Manager. Search for your firm name. If the profile appears but you can't access it, click "Request Access." Sometimes Google will show you a partially obscured email address of the current owner — enough to figure out if it's someone you know.

Step 2: Contact the current owner directly (if possible)

If you recognise the email — a former partner, an agency, an ex-employee — contact them directly. Ask them to add you as an owner, then transfer primary ownership to you. This is the fastest path. Most people comply when asked professionally.

Step 3: Submit the formal ownership request

If you can't identify or contact the current owner, go to Google Business Profile Add Gateway. Enter your exact business name. Select the claimed entity. Click "Request Access."

Fill out the form with:

Step 4: Wait 3 days

Google sends a notification to the current owner's hidden email address. They have exactly 3 days to respond. Three outcomes are possible:

If they approve: You receive an email confirmation. Access is granted instantly. Done.

If they ignore the request for 72 hours: The security restriction lifts automatically. Go back to Google Business Profile Manager, find the original access request confirmation, click "Claim" or "Verify," and complete the standard verification process — usually video. Once you pass verification, the old owner's access is automatically revoked. You become the primary owner.

If they actively deny the request: Google does not unlock the bypass button. You will be prompted to launch an official appeal or submit additional documentation — typically a utility bill, business registration certificate, or proof of address linked to the business. This goes to a Google specialist support desk for manual review. The process takes longer but is designed to prevent unauthorised takeovers of legitimately claimed profiles.

Step 5: Wait 7 days before restructuring access

After securing primary ownership, Google enforces a 7-day waiting period before you can transfer ownership to another user, remove other managers, or delete the profile. This is a security measure. Plan around it.

The pre-verification checklist

Before you start any verification process, complete these 5 checks:

# Check Action
1 Use the right account Log into the Google account you want to own the profile permanently. Ideally a workspace account like admin@yourfirm.co.uk, never a personal Gmail tied to an individual.
2 Verify your domain in Search Console Go to Google Search Console. Verify your website domain. This unlocks instant verification for many profiles.
3 Check for duplicate profiles Search your firm name on Google Maps. If you see multiple listings for the same office, note them. Do NOT create another one. After verification, merge or close duplicates.
4 Prepare documentation Have your business registration, professional body membership, and a recent utility bill or bank statement showing your address ready as PDFs.
5 Plan for the timeline Video: 3-5 working days. Postcard: up to 14 business days. Don't start verification the week before you go on holiday.

After verification: your first 5 actions

Verification is not the finish line. It's the starting line. Once you control your profile:

  1. Add a secondary owner. Settings → Managers → Add a trusted colleague. Never let one person hold the only set of keys.

  2. Audit the current managers list. Remove anyone you don't recognise. Wait the 7-day period first.

  3. Verify your business information. Name (exactly as it appears on your website and registration). Address. Phone. Website. Hours. Fix anything that's wrong.

  4. Write your business description. 750 characters. Most verified firms I audit leave this completely empty. It's the most visible text on your profile.

  5. Search for legacy profiles. Old firm names. Predecessor partnerships. Acquired practices. If they're on Google Maps, claim them and either merge or mark them as permanently closed.

The cost of doing nothing

The firm with 22 five-star reviews and an unclaimed profile had been invisible to their own reputation for 7 years. I audited this firm in detail — 22 Google Reviews. 7 Years. Zero Replies. The profile was unclaimed, so they couldn't say thank you even if they wanted to.

The firm with the 1-star review and unclaimed profiles had been watching that single negative review define their Google presence for 2 years. They couldn't respond because they didn't own the profile. Every prospect who searched their firm name saw a warning and no response from the business. The review might have been unfair. It might have been accurate. Either way, the silence made it worse.

Claiming your profile takes between 2 minutes and 2 weeks depending on the method. Leaving it unclaimed costs you every day it sits there without an owner.

This is Unclaimed #11 — the definitive guide to claiming, verifying, and reclaiming your Google Business Profile, written specifically for accounting and bookkeeping firms. Based on 300+ audits and the specific verification failures documented across UK practices.

Unclaimed is written by the founder of VindMyBusiness. I audit Google Business Profiles for accounting and bookkeeping firms. I find what's been left unclaimed — and write about what I discover. No firm names. Just patterns.

Trying to find your business on Google? Get a free scorecard — I'll personally review your profile and show you exactly what's missing. No cost. No pitch. No obligation.

More from Unclaimed: